Warning: getimagesize() [function.getimagesize]: php_network_getaddresses: getaddrinfo failed: Name or service not known in /home/bro105/public_html/fusion/forum.php on line 901
Warning: getimagesize(http://images4.pictiger.com/thumbs/85/f6a06f6f7983296b51ba6518f801ee85.th.gif) [function.getimagesize]: failed to open stream: php_network_getaddresses: getaddrinfo failed: Name or service not known in /home/bro105/public_html/fusion/forum.php on line 901 Forum Index - Reviews - HDT-S1283 CPU Cooler
Post Subject: HDT-S1283 CPU Cooler
Posted on: Feb 25, 2008
We all know that cooling is a pretty big issue when it comes to computing. It can keep everything running smooth and it can even keep hardware lasting longer. One of the most critical cooling components is the CPU Cooler. This single piece of hardware can make or break any computer, and the better you're cooler runs, the better your computer will perform. With that being said, today we'll be reviewing the High Performance CPU-cooler HDT-S1283 by Xigmatek.
The HTD-S1283 CPU Cooler is designed to work with both AMD and Intel chips, fitting a good range of socket types. One unique note that gives this cooler a bit of an edge is that the heat pipes actually touch the CPU, giving a direct heat exchange that you won't find on many other CPU Coolers.
- All Intel Socket 775 CPU
- Core 2 Extreme / Quad / Duo
- Pentium Extreme Edition / D
- Celeron D
- All AMD Socket AM2 / 754 / 939 / 940 CPU
- Athlon 64 / FX / X2 / Opteron / Sempron
The heat sink is constructed of an Aluminum Alloy for the best cooling performance. With a 120mm PWM fan attached, it's able to push 56.3 CFM while keeping the noise down to 27.2 dBA.
Out of the box, this is a pretty huge cooler. It's large enough that if you have anything smaller then a mid sized case, I'd recommend making a couple of measurements first.
Getting the cooler ready is actually pretty easy. Depending on your socket type is only the difference of using one screw or two. For the fan, you take the rubber grips, and with the long pointed end, pull it through the screw mounts of the fan. Don't worry about the heat sink mounts being aligned, once it's attached the mounts are able to move easily enough into position. For attaching the mounts to the fan I'd recommend using a pencil to help. The way I had to do this was to pull the mount with my fingers while pushing the mount with the pencil so that it all the force was moving directly up to the other screw mole. This make sure that the mount was evenly secured in all directions. Once you're this far, I'd hold off on attaching the fan to the heat sink for a little bit.
To install the heat sink, you'll want to apply a thin layer of thermal compound to your CPU (if you're upgrading heat sinks, be sure to remove all of the old thermal compound then re-apply new compound). For the installation I made the mistake of attaching the fan to the heat sink before trying to install it. The HDT-S1283 CPU Cooler has easy locking pegs to hold it in place, but even with those, it's pretty hard to reach underneath the fan to lock the pegs in place. So I'd recommend locking the CPU down first, then attaching the fan.
Since I've never had a stock cooler on this computer I'd like to run a comparison with the Freezer 7 Pro cooler. Until now, I thought that was a pretty good sized cpu cooler, but here's a few comparison shots.
* Size Comparison to stock cooler
* Size comparison to Freezer 7 Pro
To test the CPU temperature I used SpeedFan. This is a program that installs on your computer and gives you a number of temperature monitoring based on your motherboard. Like all measuring methods the accuracy is arguable, and while it may not be 100% accurate it is consistent, so it will give us some good comparable results.
Now this motherboard has never had a stock cooler on it. So we'll be comparing it with the Freezer 7 Pro. When we run our specs, we let it run for at least 20 minutes to be sure that the temperature level was stable and wasn't still changing. We decided to measure on average usage and some loaded usage. The average usage just consisted of browsing the web and checking email, nothing demanding at all. For the high load usage we usually do some gaming, but since those results aren't something that can be 100% recreated, we decided to use folding@home to really up the CPU load. While this isn't 100% identical either, it is much more consistent and will be much more comparable.
As you can see above, the HDT-S1283 CPU Cooler easily out performed the Freezer 7 Pro. The max temp from the HDT was just slightly above the min temp of the Freezer 7 Pro. As far as noise, the HDT is not even distinguishable from any other fans in my case.
I want to thanks Xigmatek for giving me the opportunity to review their HDT-S1283 CPU Cooler. I'd also like to recommend this to anyone out there who's either building a new computer or looking to improve their CPU temperatures. Now like I said if you have a very small case I'd do a couple quick measurements, but in a normal sized case it shouldn't have any problem fitting in, and it'll definitely be worth it.
I've covered a lot so if anyone has any questions or comments feel free to ask :)
it on a dual core, but a lower end (i can't grab the exact model name since i'm at work, but i know it isn't a high performer). It's a massive cooler though, lol. I'm actually really curious to see how it competes with some smaller coolers that have more heatpipes.
If con is the opposite of pro, is Congress the opposite of progress?
see now this is showing me that the people doing reviews on newegg don't actually buy things before they post.
<Username Omitted on purpose> "This cooler doesn't even touch all the way around and therefore gives terrible performance. Who ever thought that loosely packing copper heat pipes in an aluminum block would work was obviously way off on this one"
OK so maybe that wasn't so fair... here's the original post from newegg...
Too Big for its Britches
Pros: If you are a ""cutter,"" you'll save money on razor blades. Just use this HS with it's sharp edges.
Cons: Worst packaging I have ever encountered... HS was loose in box and no protection for HS base - base merely covered by a removable plastic ""sticker."" Gaps in base between heatpipes and useless chunk of metal which holds the heatpipes together means paste application will not be 100% Couldn't install push pins without removing PSU & memory module. Push pins never seated properly dispute numerous attempts.
Other Thoughts: I never met a heatsink I couldn't install... until now. Perhaps if I had taken the system apart and removed the mobo, I might have been able to do it. But as a quick upgrade, this thing is worthless.
You tell me heheh
That reminds me Sqee, Faceless you should find some way to do a surface comparison test, testing how smooth the base of the heat sink is. Another thing you might want to check that affects performance if the base of the heat sink is concave.
1. A mythical creature that exists only if you don't believe in it.
lol if you guys know where i can get a cheap depth mic (i believe thats what they're called) I'd be all for it. From my own experiences with this, i was a little curious on the surface since this has the heatpipes touching the cpu directly and from touch, I couldn't find any gaps. If they're microscopic gaps I wouldn't be to worried as thats probably small enough, lol.
The guy who commented on the thin plastic over the part that touches the CPU must have never ordered a cpu cooler in his life, I've never ever seen a cpu cooler that didn't have the protective film. It's not there for high end packaging, it's there to protect the contact area. lol obviously you don't want dust and other little bits of junk getting put in with your cpu... yeah I'll agree that some times newegg isn't all that amazing on their reviews, they're good for general guidelines though.
The only problem I had with the installation was I ended up removing the fan from the heatsink because it made getting to the pins a bit to difficult. This wasn't a big deal at all though and once the fan was off, it made installing the unit even easier then the Freezer 7 Pro, which has about the same foot print.
haha I remember hunting for a new psu once and I read things like, "This PSU caught fire so I wouldn't reccomend it to anyone" - that one worked as a nice cautious warning, lol.
If con is the opposite of pro, is Congress the opposite of progress?
I'm thinking a cheap micrometer would work out well.
Most newegg reviews are not all that bad... then there's people that remind me why I don't work at best buy any more. "I bought this case for $xxx and there was nothing in it. WHAT THE HELL. Screw you new egg >:("
I had customers yelling at me about something similar (which is why Best Buy now only sells at most two PC cases one with window, one with out) They saw that we had a case for $15 in the ad's and they were telling me how stupid I am for trying to make them buy a $200 e-machine... I even warned them that it was just the case and there was nothing in it... the guy was like "well that's just stupid why the hell wouldn't there be any thing in it? You're lying to me to get me to pay more... I'm not an idiot kid I know you make more money the more I buy" to which I explained that Best Buy is not commission so I make the same amount if the guy buys a $0.50 pencil or a $20,000 TV... He bought the case and as far as I know he never came back... he's probably still trying to figure out how to plug it in.
ANY WHO. That's why I'm glad when I see informed people writing reviews for products and not people like that guy who are pissed that we MADE him buy an empty case.